It all began with a text message.
My friend Sarah sent me a less than flattering review of A Hangman’s Diary which is the actual diary of an executioner in Nuremberg from the late 16th century to the early 17th century. The reviewer stated that if you were into German judicial functions this book might be for you. Sarah believed that I might, in fact, be this person. I replied that, yeah I could probably get into this read. To which she simply replied: “German judicial functions.”
I laughed. It is true that I have a proclivity to geek out about weird legal nuances. So for funsies, I added A Hangman’s Diary to my Christmas list, and lo and behold when Christmas came round, and I opened my yearly box of books, there it was. In all its judicial glory.
When I began reading it, I took a picture and sent it to my reading group which includes Sarah exclaiming, “Let the German judicial functions begin!”
Sarah: “I can’t believe you are reading that.”
Me: “Yes, you can.”
Sarah: “You’re right. I can.”
The book does not hesitate, it begins with an overview of medieval judicial codes, and honestly, it’s the most interesting part of the book. The diary portion written by the hangman is just a laundry list of crimes and executions. By itself, it is boring, repetitive, and bloody, but if you pay attention, and apply some of the basics of those judicial codes. You can see great discrepancies in punishment. Favors are clearly noted in the diary. For instance, thieves were to be hanged which could be a long and painful death so numerous times the hangman would note: “Beheaded as a favor.” I’m sure this favor included some extra moolah for the big guy with the ax, and it was probably a mercy that could be bestowed without flouting the law. However, due to judicial code one can be sure that the hangman slew numerous innocents, but them’s the breaks.
Generally, the diary left me feeling two things. One I wanted more. I was informed of the crime and punishment, but I wanted the circumstances. I wanted the background, the intent. And two, it made me realize that as much as we wish to believe we have moved far beyond the barbaric ways of the middle ages we haven’t. Our barbarism just has a shiner veneer which in a way makes it worse. It displays our delusions and spinelessness- no I don’t want to go back to beheading as a favor, but it has an honestly to it that I can respect.
Nevertheless, I will agree with the reviewer who began this all, this isn’t the most riveting read out there, but if you are odd, like me, and into legalize or simply wish to do a bit of humane torture to your reading group. A Hangman’s Diary might be for you.